Top-Rated Eyeliner Hacks for Every Style and Eye Shape

Eyeliner can give the eye a dramatic new look, making it brighter and beautiful. Read on to find the perfect eyeliner for your eyes.


It’s always so many other variables when looking for best beauty product. It looks good on someone with oily skin but not so much to someone with dry skin. For every person who wants a intense liquid eyeliner there’s one who prefers something less bold.

We understand that people have their own preferences when it comes to makeup, and so is eyeliners. Some people may be interested in eyeliner that will create dramatic looks, while some are in it for everyday looks. But there were some clear favorites among the makeup liners, who seemed to outperform the others. We review a large collection of eyeliners and find the right one for you.

We independently research, review and recommend what we think are the best products that meet your needs. If you buy a product through one of our retail links, we may earn a small affiliate commission.

Rimmel's Scandaleyes waterproof gel eyeliner pencil features a soft, rich gel formula for the easiest, most even lines and boldest looks.  The creamy eyeliner pencil is a waterproof formula that is smudge and transfer-proof. With up to 24 hour wear, you'll be ready for any occasion and any weather.

Maybelline eyeliner's innovative formula glides on with a creamy texture and dries quickly, giving you a beautiful look you can rely on. Maybelline eyeliner has a soft, flexible eyeliner brush that hugs the contours of your eye for the perfect application. This type of liner works well to create an edgy, fierce winged eyeliner look.  To make sure you get the perfect wing, start by tracing out the shade with an angled brush and finish with a swipe of gel liner.

This e.l.f eyeliner is everything you ever wanted. It's waterproof, vegan, and cruelty-free. It also has a creamy formula that glides on silky-smooth for bold and defined lines with intense color in the blackest black colors that won't budge. The automatic twist-up e.l.f eyeliner pencil is easy to use and stays sharp for perfect application every time. And the smudge-proof formula will last all day long.

Get a dramatic eye in an instant with this black blackest, softest, and most smudge-resistant MAC eyeliner pencils that glide on effortlessly. MAC eyeliner offers precision with a smooth, intense black line that is smudge-free for up to 16 hours and water resistant. This MAC eyeliner create the perfect pointed tip for any eye shape.

Get beautiful and long-lasting eye-catching bright colors with this colorful liquid eyeliner pen. The lilac color is perfect for a vibrant eye look for an everyday, natural appearance. It is waterproof, smudge-resistant, and long-lasting, making it perfect for most occasions. Whether you're looking for a liquid eye liner to get that ultimate cat-eye look or need a little color boost, you want the felt tip pen makes it easy to create sharp lines that will last all day.

Eyeliner FAQs

What are the different types of eyeliners?

Most people use eyeliner to enhance their eyes and/or make their eyes look more defined. The two main types of eyeliners are liquid and pencil. Liquid liners are typically long-lasting and easy to use. They can be easily smudged or wiped off with a damp cloth. Pencil liners are typically easy to use, but don't last as long as liquid liner.

Why do people wear eyeliner?

I've never used eye liner on my top or lower lashes, but I tried drawing it right above the water line. I ended up smudging it, putting on way too much product, and making myself look like a raccoon. Eyeliners aim to make your lashes look super long and luscious, but they also draw more attention to the eye which can widen them and make them look a little bit bigger.

Which eyeliner should a beginner buy?

Liquid and gel eyeliners can be difficult to apply when your hands are shaky. You'll have more success if you use a pencil. For beginners, a pencil is the most user-friendly choice because it's so easy to get right and has room for mistakes.

Is eyeliner better or eye pencil?

The softer, thick, long-wearing pencil eyeliner does wonders for the eyes if you have less folds and wrinkles.

Should an older woman wear eyeliner?

For mature women over 60, eyeliner is an absolute must when doing eye makeup. It can add structure to a face, making your eyes the main attraction. A pencil eyeliner is really good for aging eyes as it softens the lashline and thickens your fringe.

Does eyeliner make you look older or younger?

Applying dark eyeliner makes your eyes look smaller. To make it easier to work with, you might want to switch your black eyeliner for a brown one. This makes your eyes look more youthful.

Who should wear brown eyeliner?

For a natural look with your brown eyes, consider using brown eyeliner. Brown eyeliners will give you that soft touch while still making your eyes vivid and intense. Even though black ones usually give a more sharp and sleek look, if you want the perfect finishing touch, go with a brown eyeliner pencil.

Is liquid or dry eyeliner better?

Make sure your liner is fully dry, to avoid any smudges, however, we understand a lot of people prefer liquid liners because the application process is pretty smooth.

Which eyeliner is better gel or liquid?

Liquid eyeliner will give you intense black lines. Gel pencils are best for rich pigment and easy blending.

What color eyeliner is for older eyes?

Use a white (or nude) kohl pencil eyeliner on your waterline to give yourself an instant eye lift. White eyeliner is the ultimate secret weapon when it comes to giving the effect of wide, more awake, and brighter eyes. You'll want to use a smudge-free brand that will stay put all day long.

Should you put eyeliner under your eye?

I would advise against using liquid liner on the bottom lashes since it can smudge and create extra fine lines below the eyes. This is not desirable because it could cause harsh-looking eyes.